Democracy In Government

The view has long been held that in order to be in Government there must be consensus and unison on every issue among its members.

That mistaken notion has been the reason for much confusion in past administrations in Anguilla and, in some cases, led to their downfall. It is a fallacy in today’s world of increasing enlightenment and democracy to have yes men in Government. When that is the case, they are at serious odds with their conscience and the confidence of the electorate which put them in office.
A Government worthy of its name and fit for office is one that respects the individualism and independence of its members on issues of national concern. For a member to dissent is not to suggest that the Government is falling apart. On the contrary it shows that there is freedom in Government for its own members to differ on certain matters and that democracy is alive and well. For the Government to accept that right, is to be mature, sensible and worthy of applause.
We have seen in recent times, members of Government and in some cases, the Opposition, expressing their personal views on critical matters. Last week the Second Nominated Member, Claudel Romney, was quick to take up the issue of compensation for landowners in the vicinity of the Wallblake Airport expansion when he thought it should have been mentioned. That was when a motion was introduced to authorise the compulsory acquisition of their lands. On previous occasions he voiced his opinion on other delicate and sensitive issues. This week the Minister of Lands and Social Development, Eric Reid, demonstrated his objection to members of Government having overall authority in land development matters and appeals. He prefers for Government-appointed Statutory Boards to be intimately involved in the process thus ensuring fair play and transparency. Both gentlemen are to be commended for their independence.
Up to now there does not appear to be any visible acrimony in Government when its members have reason to dissent. It would be unfortunate if there was. There must be democracy in Government. Its members must not be yes men. They must freely do and say what they think is right and best for the island. The public will respect and admire them for it, for their openness and courage.